Self-Shielding Treatment to Perform Cell Calculation for Seed Furl In Th/U Pwr Using Dragon Code

Ahmed Amin El Said Abd El Hameed, Mohamed Nagy, Hanaa Abou-Gabal


Time and precision of the results are the most important factors in any code used for nuclear calculations. Despite of the high accuracy of Monte Carlo codes, MCNP and Serpent, in many cases their relatively long computational time leads to difficulties in using any of them as the main calculation code. Usually, Monte Carlo codes are used only to benchmark the results. The deterministic codes, which are usually used in nuclear reactor’s calculations, have limited precision, due to the approximations in the methods used to solve the multi-group transport equation. Self- Shielding treatment, an algorithm that produces an average cross-section defined over the complete energy domain of the neutrons in a nuclear reactor, is responsible for the biggest error in any deterministic codes. There are mainly two resonance self-shielding models commonly applied: models based on equivalence and dilution and models based on subgroup approach. The fundamental problem with any self-shielding method is that it treats any isotope as there are no other isotopes with resonance present in the reactor. The most practical way to solve this problem is to use multi-energy groups (50-200) that are chosen in a way that allows us to use all major resonances without self-shielding. In this paper, we perform cell calculations, for a fresh seed fuel pin which is used in thorium/uranium reactors, by solving 172 energy group transport equation using the deterministic DRAGON code, for the two types of self-shielding models (equivalence and dilution models and subgroup models) Using WIMS-D5 and DRAGON data libraries. The results are then tested by comparing it with the stochastic MCNP5 code.  We also tested the sensitivity of the results to a specific change in self-shielding method implemented, for example the effect of applying Livolant-Jeanpierre Normalization scheme and Rimman Integration improvement on the equivalence and dilution method, and the effect of using Ribbon extended approach on sub-group method.  The results of Kinf, in case of fresh seed fuel pin which is used in thorium/uranium PWR, show that a high accuracy is obtained by using some specific self-shielding modules.  It is also shown that for the implemented self-shielding models DRAGON library is more reliable than WIMS-D5 library, and that applying Livolant-Jeanpierre Normalization scheme is essential with the equivalence and dilution self-shielding method.



Nuclear Cell Calculation; Self-Shielding Treatment; Precision of Nuclear Deterministic Codes

Full Text:



M. Shafii, Z. Su’ud, Abdul Waris, N. Kurniaish “ Nuclear Fuel Cell Calculation Using Collision Probability with Linear Non Flat Flux Approach” , World Journal of Nuclear Science and Technology, 2012,2,49-53

DušanĆalić, MarjanKromar, Andrej Trkov, “Use of Monte Carlo and Deterministic Codes for Calculation of Plutonium Radial Distribution in a Fuel Cell”, International conference of Nuclear Energy for Europe, 2011

A. H´ebert“ Development of a new resonance self-shielding methodology based on probability tables”, Nuclear Mathematical and Computational Sciences,(2003)

D. Wang, “Optimization of a Seed and Blanket Thorium-Uranium Fuel Cycle for Pressurized Water Reactors” PHD thesis, MIT, June 2003

B. Foad, H. Mansour, M. Aziz “Neutronic and Burn-up Calculations of Heterogeneous Thorium/ Uranium Fuel in Pressurized Water Reactors” KERNTCHNICK, KT110092. (2010)

MCNP Team, MCNP User Manual -A general Monte Carlo N-Particle Transport Code, Version 5.

G. Marleau, A. H´ebert and R. Roy, “User Guide for DRAGON Version4” Technical Report, Nuclear Engineering Department, Technical report, IGE-294.



  • There are currently no refbacks.

Copyright (c) 2015 Ahmed Amin El Said Abd El Hameed, Mohamed Nagy, Hanaa Abou-Gabal

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

Renewable Energy and Sustainable Development

E-ISSN: 2356-8569

P-ISSN: 2356-8518


Published by:

Academy Publishing Center (APC)

Arab Academy for Science, Technology and Maritime Transport (AASTMT)

Alexandria, Egypt